Mailing List CGatePro@mail.stalker.com Message #96483
From: Bret Miller <bret.miller@wcg.org>
Subject: Re: loop
Date: Wed, 15 Oct 2008 14:10:06 -0700
To: CommuniGate Pro Discussions <CGatePro@mail.stalker.com>
I'm not quite sure why I'm trying to answer this, but I am. I tried this very setup and it worked perfectly for me. Admitted, my setup must be different because when I mirror to local users, it doesn't send it back to my server using SMTP.

So here are my thoughts:

1. We don't see those return messages coming in on SMTPI. You should, if you haven't, turn on full logging and look at the RCPT TO commands in the inbound messages in that loop. "Any recipient" has to match ALL of those addresses properly or the condition fails (or in this case passes because it's negative).

2. There is always the possibility that you have a space or extra character in your "Any recipient" list causing it to think the addresses don't match. I would think these would be case-insensitive, but I'd make the case the same in both lists anyway to make sure.

Running CGPro 5.2.8 on Windows Server 2003 here, and it works for me.

Bret

On 10/15/2008 8:15 AM, Bob wrote:
*This message was transferred with a trial version of CommuniGate(r) Pro*
Hi. I have a rule that distributes an email to a couple of people when it is from a certain address.  It actually works, but then loops and sends me 10 or 15 before it finally decides Im too stupid and stops. :)

Rule:

From                          in      webmaster.conndot@po.state.ct.us
each recipient               not in      <email addresses it goes to>

action:
Mirror to         <email addresses it goes to>

Log:

09:44:43.781 2 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11154] sent to [216.32.181.22]:25, got:250 Ok: queued as D49F71988062
09:44:43.781 4 SMTP(nwnit.com) [11154] batch relayed
09:44:43.796 2 DEQUEUER [11154] SMTP(nwnit.com)dvonholtz@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:43.796 2 DEQUEUER [11154] SMTP(nwnit.com)jdewey@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:43.796 2 DEQUEUER [11154] SMTP(nwnit.com)mbesso@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:43.796 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RSET\r\n
09:44:43.796 2 QUEUE([11154]) deleted
09:44:43.953 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:43.953 4 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11156] sending
09:44:43.953 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: MAIL FROM:<webmaster.conndot@po.state.ct.us> SIZE=4224\r\n
09:44:44.093 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:44.093 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<dvonholtz@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:44.218 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:44.218 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<jdewey@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:44.343 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:44.343 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<mbesso@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:44.468 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:44.468 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: DATA\r\n
09:44:44.609 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 354 End data with <CR><LF>.<CR><LF>
09:44:44.609 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: Received: from <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\n  by maxboostracing.com (CommuniGate Pro RULES 5.2.5 _trial_)\r\n  with RULES id 11156; Wed, 15 Oct 2008 09:44:39 -0400\r\nX-Autogenerated: Mirror\r\nResent-From: <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\nRes
09:44:44.609 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: ovember 3, 2008.\r\n\r\nFor more information, please visit the ConnDOT website: http://www.ct.gov/dot/cwp/view.asp?a=2135&Q=424946\r\n.\r\n
09:44:44.906 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok: queued as E31BE1988087
09:44:44.906 2 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11156] sent to [216.32.181.22]:25, got:250 Ok: queued as E31BE1988087
09:44:44.906 4 SMTP(nwnit.com) [11156] batch relayed
09:44:44.906 2 DEQUEUER [11156] SMTP(nwnit.com)dvonholtz@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:44.906 2 DEQUEUER [11156] SMTP(nwnit.com)jdewey@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:44.906 2 DEQUEUER [11156] SMTP(nwnit.com)mbesso@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:44.906 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RSET\r\n
09:44:44.906 2 QUEUE([11156]) deleted
09:44:45.031 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:45.031 4 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11158] sending
09:44:45.031 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: MAIL FROM:<webmaster.conndot@po.state.ct.us> SIZE=4782\r\n
09:44:45.156 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:45.156 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<dvonholtz@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:45.281 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:45.281 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<jdewey@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:45.406 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:45.406 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<mbesso@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:45.546 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:45.546 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: DATA\r\n
09:44:45.671 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 354 End data with <CR><LF>.<CR><LF>
09:44:45.671 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: Received: from <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\n  by maxboostracing.com (CommuniGate Pro RULES 5.2.5 _trial_)\r\n  with RULES id 11158; Wed, 15 Oct 2008 09:44:39 -0400\r\nX-Autogenerated: Mirror\r\nResent-From: <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\nRes
09:44:45.671 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: state.ct.us>\r\nMessage-Id: <200810150945656.SM01484@DeltaConX3.po.state.ct.us>\r\n\r\n*This message was transferred with a trial version of CommuniGate(r) Pro*\r\nMilling and Resurfacing - Route 57 (Georgetown Road) from Trails End Road to Redding Town Lin
09:44:45.953 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok: queued as F1CF7198808B
09:44:45.953 2 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11158] sent to [216.32.181.22]:25, got:250 Ok: queued as F1CF7198808B
09:44:45.953 4 SMTP(nwnit.com) [11158] batch relayed
09:44:45.953 2 DEQUEUER [11158] SMTP(nwnit.com)dvonholtz@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:45.953 2 DEQUEUER [11158] SMTP(nwnit.com)jdewey@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:45.953 2 DEQUEUER [11158] SMTP(nwnit.com)mbesso@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:45.953 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RSET\r\n
09:44:45.953 2 QUEUE([11158]) deleted
09:44:46.078 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:46.078 4 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11160] sending
09:44:46.078 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: MAIL FROM:<webmaster.conndot@po.state.ct.us> SIZE=5340\r\n
09:44:46.203 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:46.203 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<dvonholtz@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:46.328 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:46.328 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<jdewey@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:46.468 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:46.468 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<mbesso@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:46.593 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:46.593 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: DATA\r\n
09:44:46.718 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 354 End data with <CR><LF>.<CR><LF>
09:44:46.718 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: Received: from <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\n  by maxboostracing.com (CommuniGate Pro RULES 5.2.5 _trial_)\r\n  with RULES id 11160; Wed, 15 Oct 2008 09:44:39 -0400\r\nX-Autogenerated: Mirror\r\nResent-From: <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\nRes
09:44:46.718 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: 3.po.state.ct.us [159.247.5.95] by pop.state.ct.us\r\n  (SMTPD-9.23) id A40D0380; Wed, 15 Oct 2008 09:45:49 -0400\r\nReceived: from (www.dsf.state.ct.us [159.247.0.240]) by DeltaConX3.po.state.ct.us with smtp\r\n\t id 32e0_54d1628e_9abf_11dd_9d5f_00137253bd
09:44:47.062 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok: queued as 098941988062
09:44:47.062 2 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11160] sent to [216.32.181.22]:25, got:250 Ok: queued as 098941988062
09:44:47.062 4 SMTP(nwnit.com) [11160] batch relayed
09:44:47.062 2 DEQUEUER [11160] SMTP(nwnit.com)dvonholtz@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:47.062 2 DEQUEUER [11160] SMTP(nwnit.com)jdewey@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:47.062 2 DEQUEUER [11160] SMTP(nwnit.com)mbesso@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:47.062 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RSET\r\n
09:44:47.062 2 QUEUE([11160]) deleted
09:44:47.187 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:47.187 4 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11162] sending
09:44:47.187 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: MAIL FROM:<webmaster.conndot@po.state.ct.us> SIZE=5898\r\n
09:44:47.328 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:47.328 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<dvonholtz@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:47.453 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:47.453 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<jdewey@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:47.593 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:47.593 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: RCPT TO:<mbesso@nwnit.com>\r\n
09:44:47.703 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok
09:44:47.703 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: DATA\r\n
09:44:47.828 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 354 End data with <CR><LF>.<CR><LF>
09:44:47.828 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: Received: from <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\n  by maxboostracing.com (CommuniGate Pro RULES 5.2.5 _trial_)\r\n  with RULES id 11162; Wed, 15 Oct 2008 09:44:39 -0400\r\nX-Autogenerated: Mirror\r\nResent-From: <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\nRes
09:44:47.828 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: anned with Niversoft PolluStop v2.5.2a\r\nReceived: from <MAILER-DAEMON@maxboostracing.com>\r\n  by maxboostracing.com (CommuniGate Pro RULES 5.2.5 _trial_)\r\n  with RULES id 11151; Wed, 15 Oct 2008 09:44:38 -0400\r\nX-Autogenerated: Mirror\r\nResent-From:
09:44:48.109 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 250 Ok: queued as 279C81988062
09:44:48.109 2 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) [11162] sent to [216.32.181.22]:25, got:250 Ok: queued as 279C81988062
09:44:48.109 4 SMTP(nwnit.com) [11162] batch relayed
09:44:48.109 2 DEQUEUER [11162] SMTP(nwnit.com)dvonholtz@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:48.109 2 DEQUEUER [11162] SMTP(nwnit.com)jdewey@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:48.109 2 DEQUEUER [11162] SMTP(nwnit.com)mbesso@nwnit.com relayed: relayed via mail.global.frontbridge.com
09:44:48.109 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) out: QUIT\r\n
09:44:48.109 2 QUEUE([11162]) deleted
09:44:48.250 5 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) inp: 221 Bye
09:44:48.250 5 SMTP(nwnit.com) record disposed
09:44:48.250 4 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) closing connection
09:44:48.250 4 SMTP-000996(nwnit.com) releasing stream
09:44:53.671 5 SMTP stream thread finished
09:44:57.765 5 SMTP stream thread finished



#############################################################
This message is sent to you because you are subscribed to
 the mailing list <CGatePro@mail.stalker.com>.
To unsubscribe, E-mail to: <CGatePro-off@mail.stalker.com>
To switch to the DIGEST mode, E-mail to <CGatePro-digest@mail.stalker.com>
To switch to the INDEX mode, E-mail to <CGatePro-index@mail.stalker.com>
Send administrative queries to  <CGatePro-request@mail.stalker.com>
Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster